Places
Wisconsin LGBTQ History Project Fundraiser
If you appreciate the History Project's work, we hope you'll support the second fundraiser in our 29-year history!
We are a self-funded, independent, all-volunteer, non-profit team -- and we provide most services FREE to the community.
Bar Food | Sailor Bar
400 N Plankinton Ave
Milwaukee, WI 53203
State Region
Southeast WI
Neighborhood
Historic Fifth Ward
Year Opened: 1933
Year Closed: 1959
Exact Date Opened: Unknown
Exact Date Closed: Unknown
Clientele Primarily Identified As
Gay
Logo:
The Old Mill Inn was a historic "sailor bar" mere blocks from Wisconsin Avenue from 1921 to 1958. The pre-Civil War Cream CIty brick building, used by Fairbanks Morse as a grain elevator, was otherwise vacant. Even in the 1920s, the Old Mill Inn was a known meeting place for men seeking men. In the 1940s, the bar was acquired by a Greek nightlife syndicate and managed by Stella Zeppos and her husband, Peter La Bracke. It became Mary's, a Harry Kaminsky-funded "gay for pay" venture, in 1958, and the scene of the Black Nite Uprising in August 1961.
INPUT ALWAYS WELCOME!
We are always looking for photos of the exterior and interiors of Bars and other Places, as well as information about ownership, activities and opening and closing background info about Places. We welcome your input and photos!
INPUT ALWAYS WELCOME!
We are always looking for photos of the exterior and interiors of Bars and other Places, as well as information about ownership, activities and opening and closing background info about Places. We welcome your input and photos!
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
© 2025 Wisconsin LGBTQ History Project. All Rights Reserved.