Pink Pony

Bar Women | Cocktail Lounge

1834 W. North Ave
Milwaukee, WI 53205

State Region

Southeast WI

Neighborhood

North Side

Year Opened: 1953
Year Closed: 1976

Exact Date Opened: Unknown
Exact Date Closed: Unknown

Clientele Primarily Identified As

Gay

Logo:

The Pink Pony, a North Avenue gay bar, was known for its seductive atmosphere, fancy decor, and specialized ice cream drinks. When Albert Tusa's Tic Toc Club collapsed in 1955, he took over the Pink Pony and made it a high-end cocktail lounge. The bar was described with subtle "wink-wink" gay references in nightlife articles. It was a favorite stop for lesbians before and after dancing at the nearby Big T. Despite deep neighborhood decline after 1967, including civil unrest, Park West Freeway clearance, and urban renewal, the Pink Pony survived until it was destroyed by arson in 1976.